10 Simple Common Decluttering Mistakes That Keep You Stuck
Introduction
You know that moment when you’ve decided to finally get your house in order—but hours later, you’re just sitting in the middle of a mess, wondering how it got worse instead of better? Yeah. Me too.
Decluttering is supposed to make us feel lighter, freer, and calmer. But sometimes it just feels overwhelming, stressful, and downright defeating. And for years, I couldn’t figure out why.
Until I realized—I was making a bunch of tiny (but powerful) common decluttering mistakes that kept me spinning my wheels.
Today, I want to share those with you. Not from a “perfect home” perspective, but from someone who has literally cried into a pile of old birthday cards trying to make sense of it all.
So if you’ve ever felt stuck, frustrated, or just totally unsure where to start, this is for you. Here are the most common decluttering mistakes I see—and how to get past them.
1. Trying to Declutter Everything at Once
One of the most common decluttering mistakes is going too big, too fast. You look around and decide you’re going to tackle your entire house in a day. Spoiler alert: this rarely works.
When I first started, I treated decluttering like a one-weekend project. I got overwhelmed fast and ended up with piles everywhere and zero real progress. Suddenly my overwhelmed was bigger than when I started.
Why It Fails:
Decluttering is emotional and time-consuming. When you try to do it all at once, it’s easy to burn out or end up with an even bigger mess.
What to Do Instead:
Start small. I mean tiny! Pick one drawer, one shelf, or one category. Give yourself a quick win and build from there. Progress is better than perfection.
2. Decluttering Without a Plan
Another of the common decluttering mistakes? Jumping in without a strategy. You might start in the kitchen, get distracted by a pile of old mail, then wander into the garage.
I used to declutter by making piles all over the place with no plan for where things would go. Cue the chaos!
Why It Fails:
You end up with multiple half-finished projects and a sense of chaos.
What to Do Instead:
Pick one room or one type of item (like clothes or books). Keep it simple. Use the 3-box method: Keep, Donate, Trash. Set a timer, and finish one area before moving to the next. Deal with the boxes when you’re done — not 3 weeks later!
3. Getting Stuck in the “Just in Case” Trap
Ohhh this one. I kept backup baking pans (I don’t bake), stacks of old cables (no idea what they went to), and enough tote bags to last a lifetime.
“I might need this someday…” Sound familiar? This is one of the most common decluttering mistakes that keeps clutter in your home.
Why It Fails:
Most of the time, “just in case” never comes. These items take up space and weigh you down.
What to Do Instead:
Ask yourself: Have I used this in the past year? Would I buy it again today? If not, let it go. If the worst-case scenario happens, you can probably replace the item. Your space (and your peace!) is too valuable to waste.
4. Letting Guilt Guide Your Decisions
This one hit me hard. I had gifts I never used, heirlooms I didn’t love, and clothes I never wore—but I kept them because I felt like I should.
We often hold onto gifts we don’t love, inherited items we don’t use, or expensive purchases we regret—all because of guilt. This is a sneaky one of the common decluttering mistakes.
Why It Fails:
Your home ends up filled with items that don’t reflect who you are now. Guilt keeps you stuck in the past.
What to Do Instead:
Remind yourself: the person who gave it to you wouldn’t want you to feel burdened. Let go with love and gratitude.
5. Decluttering Without Considering Your Life Stage
Your needs shift over time. What worked when your kids were toddlers might not work now. Ignoring your current lifestyle is one of the a common decluttering mistakes that leads to frustration.
When we started to prepare for a downsize move, I found bins and bins of my boys’ toys and clothes. I was just trying to hold on to those precious memories of when they were little. I kept a couple adorable outfits that I hope my future grandchildren might wear for a picture one day and a few toys with fun memories. I let the rest go, and it felt good!
Why It Fails:
You organize for the life you had, not the life you have.
What to Do Instead:
Ask: What do I need from this space now? Then declutter with that in mind. Make room for the season you’re in.
6. Keeping Too Many “Maybe” Piles
What if I need it one day? What if it comes back in style? What if my kids want it later?
Sound familiar?
Some people never decide. They make a “keep” pile, a “donate” pile… and a “maybe” pile that never gets smaller. It’s one of the most paralyzing common decluttering mistakes.
Why It Fails:
“Maybe” piles prolong the process. Indecision becomes a form of clutter.
What to Do Instead:
Remember indecision is a decision. Set a clear rule: if it goes in the “maybe” pile, you must decide by the end of your session. Or eliminate the “maybe” pile altogether.
Trust yourself. Free up the space and energy.
7. Organizing Before Decluttering
Buying bins and baskets feels productive—but it’s one of the most expensive and common decluttering mistakes.
Why It Fails:
You end up organizing clutter instead of removing it. Storage solutions become a crutch.
What to Do Instead:
Declutter first. Read that again! Only after you’ve pared things down should you buy containers (if you even need them).
8. Holding onto Things Because of Sunk Cost
You spent money on it, so you should keep it, right? This mindset is one of the hidden common decluttering mistakes that traps people into keeping unwanted stuff.
Why It Fails:
The money is already spent. Keeping the item doesn’t bring it back.
What to Do Instead:
Ask: Does this add value to my life today? If not, let it go and consider it a learning experience.
Let. It. Go!
That makes me think of my favorite book that helped me so much on my decluttering journey: Let It Go, by Peter Walsh. Highly recommend!
9. Comparing Your Home to Pinterest
I used to scroll Instagram, see picture-perfect pantries, and immediately feel defeated. I mean…….my house didn’t look like that. I thought I was doing it wrong.
This might be the most emotionally damaging of the common decluttering mistakes of all. You see perfectly styled photos and feel like your space will never measure up.
Why It Fails:
It sets unrealistic expectations and robs you of joy. Your home should work for you, not social media.
What to Do Instead:
Focus on how your home feels, not how it looks. Function and peace matter more than color-coded closets.
You might also like 5 Emotional Benefits of Decluttering.
10. Not Decluttering Regularly
Decluttering isn’t a one-time event. It’s a habit. Skipping maintenance is another of the common decluttering mistakes that causes clutter to creep back in.
Why It Fails:
Even the most organized space needs upkeep. Life brings in new items every day.
What to Do Instead:
Set a recurring declutter date—monthly or seasonally. Regular check-ins prevent the overwhelm from building back up.
When I’m shopping, before I purchase anything new, I visualize the item that will leave my home to make room for the new item. It makes me pause and really think about what I’m getting ready to purchase. Am I willing to let something else from my home go to let this item in? There have been many times when I walked away saving me not just money but the time and energy to figure out what to get rid of in my home. This has been a game-changer for me!
Bonus Tips to Avoid Common Decluttering Mistakes
Use the “One In, One Out” Rule: Every time you bring something new into your home, let go of something else.
Create a Donation Station: Keep a bin in your closet or garage for items to donate. When it’s full, drop it off.
Celebrate Progress: Take before-and-after photos. Reward yourself with something other than “stuff.”
Final Thoughts
Decluttering isn’t just about clearing out physical stuff—it’s about reclaiming your time, space, and peace of mind. By recognizing and avoiding these common decluttering mistakes, you’ll be better equipped to make real, lasting changes.
You don’t have to be perfect. You just have to start. Whether it’s one drawer, one room, or one big lifestyle shift—your journey is yours.
Let go of what’s not serving you. You’ve got this.
For more organization inspiration, be sure and check out 97 Best Organization Ideas.
Note: Some links in this post are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my work—it helps me keep creating helpful content!
💛 Ready to take the next step? Download my free guide, “Declutter Your Home in 30 Days“!
Be sure and check out all the ways you can work with me.
